DNS Monitor vs Cloudflare DNS Analytics
Comparing DNS Monitor and Cloudflare's DNS analytics. Independent monitoring vs provider-specific analytics.
Cloudflare is a powerhouse in the DNS space. Their DNS service is fast, reliable, and offers robust analytics for domains using their platform. But Cloudflare's DNS analytics and DNS Monitor serve fundamentally different purposes. One is a provider's view of its own data. The other is an independent monitoring tool that works regardless of where your DNS is hosted.
Understanding these differences is especially important if you run a multi-provider DNS strategy or need to verify your Cloudflare configuration from the outside.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | DNS Monitor | Cloudflare DNS Analytics |
|---|---|---|
| Works with any DNS provider | ✓ | ✗ (Cloudflare only) |
| DNS record change detection | ✓ | ✗ |
| Propagation tracking | ✓ | ✗ |
| Query volume analytics | ✗ | ✓ |
| Traffic pattern insights | ✗ | ✓ |
| DNSSEC status monitoring | ✓ | ✓ |
| Multi-location verification | ✓ | Limited |
| Diff views for changes | ✓ | ✗ |
| Audit log of record changes | ✓ | ✓ (via API/Audit Log) |
| Independent third-party view | ✓ | ✗ |
What Cloudflare Does Well
Cloudflare's DNS analytics provide valuable data that DNS Monitor does not attempt to replicate. Their dashboard shows query volume, response codes, top queried records, and traffic patterns over time. This data is useful for capacity planning, identifying abuse patterns, and understanding how your DNS is being used.
Cloudflare also provides one of the fastest authoritative DNS services available, with a global anycast network and an impressive uptime track record. Their audit log tracks changes made through the Cloudflare dashboard or API, which helps with accountability within teams.
For domains that live entirely within the Cloudflare ecosystem, their built-in analytics cover a lot of ground.
Where Cloudflare's Approach Has Gaps
The fundamental limitation is scope. Cloudflare analytics only cover domains using Cloudflare's DNS. If you use Route 53, Google Cloud DNS, Azure DNS, or any other provider for some or all of your domains, Cloudflare gives you nothing for those.
Provider-locked visibility
Cloudflare can only show you data for domains on their platform. Most organizations use multiple DNS providers across their portfolio. You end up with fragmented monitoring.
No external verification
Cloudflare analytics tell you what Cloudflare sees from the inside. They do not verify what the rest of the internet sees when resolving your domain. An independent check from outside the provider is essential for confirming actual resolution behavior.
No change detection from the resolver perspective
Cloudflare's audit log tracks changes made through their interface, but it does not detect changes from the perspective of a DNS resolver querying your domain. If a record behaves differently than expected due to caching, delegation issues, or provider-side bugs, Cloudflare's internal view may not reflect that.
Analytics, not monitoring
Cloudflare provides analytics — data you look at. DNS Monitor provides monitoring — it watches and alerts you. The difference matters when speed of detection is critical.
These tools are complementary
Cloudflare DNS analytics tell you how your DNS is being queried. DNS Monitor tells you what resolvers actually see when they query your records. Running both gives you a complete picture.
Provider-Independent DNS Monitoring
DNS Monitor works with any DNS provider. Get change detection, propagation tracking, and alerts regardless of where your DNS is hosted.
When to Choose Cloudflare DNS Analytics
All your domains are on Cloudflare
If every domain you manage uses Cloudflare DNS, their analytics provide rich traffic and query data that a record-monitoring tool does not cover.
You need query volume data
Understanding how many queries your domain receives, which record types are most popular, and spotting anomalous traffic patterns is a strength of Cloudflare's analytics.
You want integrated security insights
Cloudflare ties DNS analytics into their broader security platform, including DDoS mitigation and firewall rules. If you use Cloudflare for security, their DNS data feeds into that picture.
When to Choose DNS Monitor
You use multiple DNS providers
Most organizations have domains spread across different providers. DNS Monitor gives you a single pane of glass for all of them.
You need independent verification
Trusting your DNS provider to tell you everything is fine is like asking a student to grade their own test. An independent monitor verifies what the rest of the internet actually sees.
You need change detection and alerting
When a record changes unexpectedly, you need to know immediately. DNS Monitor detects changes and alerts you, rather than waiting for you to check a dashboard.
You need propagation visibility
After making DNS changes, DNS Monitor confirms how those changes appear across global resolvers, which Cloudflare's analytics do not show.
Our Honest Take
Cloudflare is an excellent DNS provider and their analytics are genuinely useful for understanding query patterns and traffic. We are not suggesting you stop using them. But analytics from your DNS provider are not the same as independent DNS monitoring. They serve your provider's perspective, not the resolver's perspective.
If all your domains live on Cloudflare and you only need traffic data, their built-in analytics may be sufficient. But if you need to know what the internet actually sees when it resolves your domains, if you use multiple providers, or if you need proactive change detection, an independent monitoring layer is essential.
The best DNS monitoring strategy includes both internal analytics from your provider and external verification from an independent tool.
Monitor DNS Independently
DNS Monitor provides the external verification layer your DNS stack needs. Works with Cloudflare, Route 53, Google Cloud DNS, and every other provider.
Part of Boring Tools—boring tools for boring jobs.